AWKWARD ZOMBIE

lol no

barely anything in doctor who goes the way we expect it to, so if you're right i'll personally applaud you

unrelated to doctor who but relevant to mr writer
Moffat is one of the writers for the Tintin movie.

Relevant: your avatar

I called River Song being Amy/Rory's daughter at the moment when she arrived in the Weeping Angels two-parter in Series 5.

I also called Amy actually being a Ganger and pregnant the moment the episode was previewed after The Doctor's Wife.

I've been fairly bang on with my guesses so far this entire run of Moffat's. But one thing I don't feel confident on is this idea I had: Amy/Rory/The Doctor/"Sexy", "Idris", the TARDIS all breathed in Nephew who was possessed by HOUSE. Could HOUSE still technically have remained inside of their bodies on a very low level to not be detected? And at a later instance be pulled out of one of or all of them and be put into the Silence's TARDIS clone as their own TARDIS Matrix teaming up for vengeance on The Doctor? Could be interesting to have them pop up now and then with that idea in mind for an episode every Series or every other Series.

It's been two days and no-one's commented on the new episode? Huh.

All in all it was okay, aside from the generic situation (though at least they acknowledged it as such), but I felt they covered too much in one episode, what with Revealing Megs' identity, bringing in River, having her assassinate the Doctor, then turn good all in one episode. I just feel it would have flowed better had they split these events up over several episodes (e.g. have Megs accompany them on a couple of adventures before dying, though that could be a little out of character, or have River chasing after them for a few episodes before successfully 'killing' the Doctor). Still, there were some fantastic bits about it ("Shut up, Hitler, and get in the cupboard"; the scenes with the guns with them 'outsmarting' each other; the sonic cane and suit (no "Top hats are cool" though...)) so overall a good episode. Those antibodies looked ridiculous though.

Well for some reason either the website or my computer isn't working right so I haven't been able to see it.

I have a few qualms with the continuity of the episode's events, mostly because in a prior episode River explicitly said that "The Tenth wasn't her Doctor" but has never REALLY made it feel like The Eleventh was aside from a single facebattle. Other than that, it was only playful flirting and nothing more.

Also, Mels was ridiculously obvious, but there was one incredible flaw in that idea. She said blatantly "last time I did this I wound up a toddler in the middle of New York." while also saying "It took me ages to find you." in regards to finding Amy/Rory. So... between her little girl regen that died at the end of Day Of The Moon and the toddler in NY, she was able to locate Amy/Rory, and insert herself into their lives as kids? Would Amy/Rory not ever question or try to find her "parents" after being punished so much? Wouldn't the school system she was in need a legal guardian to enroll her there in the first place or need a legal guardian to speak to after being in detention or imprisoned? Not to mention, when Amy told The Doctor River's name was "Melody Pond" for the first time after her rescue in "A Good Man Goes To War", it would be a common thing to say "We named her after our best friend Mels growing up." when the Doctor looked confused as to why they named her Melody.

A lot of common sense mistakes like that kind of made me slowly dislike the River Song character. She's been far too over-exposed now and has lost any and all meaning to me. I hope with the Doctor's sentiments of "no, we can't ever look for her. We have too much foreknowledge and that's too dangerous to her at this point in her timeline" that we don't get any more River Song until at least two Series from now when everyone forgets her, maybe skip her entirely next Series and save her for a big return in the 50th Anniversary Series.

Also one other small annoyance to me was the Hitler being put into the cupboard thing. This man is a genius in his own right, not morally correct, but a genius. You're telling me during the 5 or 10 minutes of the Doctor/Melody back and forth of the gun switching this man couldn't find a way to bust down a freaking flimsy wooden door of a cupboard? A man known for his rage over defiance?

You forget that she was raised to kill the Doctor. Her legal guardian was probably the eye patch lady. They placed her there to make sure that Rory and Amy were safe, would like each other, be safe until they meet the Doctor, marry each other, and then lead her to the Doctor. She was making sure her timeline didn't become a paradox before she kills the Doctor.

mel was the laziest piece of shit writing so far and her actor was bad

episode was good though

Pretty much this.

Let's Kill Hitler is probably my favorite episode name for anything. But yeah, that episode could have flowed better.

I think locking Hitler in the cupboard and "Shut up, Hitler." were the best parts.

I really don't want this show to become "What other hysterically historical moments in time can we turn into a comedic sketch for a few one-liner zings?" sort of deal.

what show are you watching

Comedy in my Doctor Who?

I'm going back to Scrubs and House instead!