??? wrote:
People said Tim Burton was also a genius when my sister said she doesn't like him.
These guys are not "geniuses" just because they make a bunch of similar movies and have a "theme." One just does a bunch of fighting and horror over and over, and the other thinks every day is Halloween.
If they made a movie together, it'd be the dancing skeletons doing karate!
Ack, I'm not referring to Burton. I've never enjoyed any of his films all that much. QT, on the other hand, although all of films do contain action, and similar criminal underworld type themes, all of his films are profoundly different. Take Reservoir Dogs and Pulp Fiction for example. Sure, they are set in the same universe, contain similar ideas, etc, but the execution is completely different. Reservoir Dogs is a gritty, violent film filled with betrayal, told through the experiences of the individual Reservoir Dogs. Pulp Fiction is a delightful and hilarious, although still violent, depiction of the criminal life style.
And what are you taking about with excessive fighting? Kill Bill does have a lot of fights, like you said, but, if you were focusing in on the action of the film, you were missing the point. QT uses action very well, I think. It's not overly done, it's well choreographed, and it furthers the character's role. But, the thing that makes QT's films amazing is not the fights, it's the extremely well written the dialog, the fact that anything can happen, the amazing soundtrack, and the stunning way he directs his actors.
QT is a genius, and you obviously weren't paying good enough attention to his movies to notice it. Yeah, I know I sound like a pompous fanboy right now, but, seriously, the only flaw I see in a lot of his films is the fact that he puts himself into the story. [spoiler]It was alright in Reservoir Dogs, though, because he got shot in the face.[/spoiler]