Marcato wrote:
I saw The Battle of Five Armies today, and I know I'm going to sound like I hate fun, but that was the most boring 80% fight scene movie I've ever seen. Granted, I haven't read the Silmarillion or anything outside the main four books, but this movie felt like Lord of the Rings fan fiction, what with the dwarves, humans(IN NO FUCKING ARMOR), elves, and orcs all fighting each other and Galadriel, Elrond, Saruman, and goddamn Radagast all coming to bail out Gandalf's booty, also eagles because why the fuck not?
I saw it yesterday and I mostly agree. I wouldn't say it was boring but it was definitely full of clichés (like Thorin
changing his mind and Bolg
getting back from certain death for the 14th time in 10 minutes and the entirety of Legolas, Thauriel and Thranduil's dialogue, but I enjoyed it.
Some of the CGI was very bad though.
I've read the LOTR books but not the Hobbit. Did graboids show up in the book? That was a ridiculous scene (but not as much as
Legolas climbing freefalling stones).
The scene at Dol Guldur was really fanficcy and dumb, but my real complaint is that the ending seemed botched. Maybe they didn't want to do like in ROTK and have a 5h30 movie with 7 epilogues but they could have added a couple scenes that show us how things settle after the battle. Maybe I missed it but I think we never see Grima 2.0 after
he leaves Dale with his gold-filled bra, and we definitely
never see
Saruman, Elrond and Galadriel after Gandalf escapes Dol Guldur. What happens to the dwarves and townspeople and everyone other than Bilbo?
Also the last scene with Thranduil and Legolas sounded like spinoff-bait to me and I'm scared. They don't have the rights to anything other than LOTR and The Hobbit, but there's still cheddar to be made off of those, and they had no qualms about wedging the Necromancer into The Hobbit even though it canonically happened centuries earlier, so I think they're going to make some derivative movies to milk the franchise while they can.