Marcato wrote:
Kamak wrote:

Whitney goes back to her house
Evidence Bullet: Whitney's keys
YOU'VE GOT THAT WRONG!
"If events played out the way you described it, rookie, then it seems unlikely that Whitney would be unable to get into her house after committing the murder."

"She would have locked her door in order to prevent someone from breaking and entering!"
Cori wrote:

"When I heard that Punchy had purchased medicine yesterday, I was almost certain that he was the one who drugged me." Whitney took her paws away from her face, frowning. "But when I poked around in his home, the medicine bottle was sealed. Not only that, but he wasn't even
near me yesterday. There would have been no opportunity for him to drug me."

"I think these two points can be easily explained away."

"Isabelle, was Whitney's door locked or unlocked when you went there?"

"Err... I think it was unlocked. The handle turned easily, but I didn't want to just barge in... j-just in case she wasn't dressed or... you know... dead..."

"So, it's possible that Whitney left her door unlocked, killed Cranston went home, not knowing her keys were at Cranston's house, and passed out from being drugged
(if she was drugged at all)?"

"I... I guess so? But Whitney would never-"

"Let's move onto the second point. As you know, I'm a very kind animal who just wants the best for each of you... so to that end, I have these..."
He holds out a set of ID cards.
"I'm sure it seems scummy, but I have the ability to put things in your closets through these spare ID cards. Poor Punchy seemed like he really needed some medicine, so I put some in there..."

"However, I can't remember how many bottles I put in there..."

"It could have been 1... or maybe even 2..."

"So... he definitely could have been faking an illness and drugged dear old Whitney..."

"And still had enough for himself."

"It's sad to know that my generousity could be taken advantage of like that... to think someone could potentially murder and get away with it because of me... how disappointing, upupu~"
TerraChimaera wrote:
"Wait, hang on... did they say yesterday? I bought my medicine two days ago..."
Tom gestures to Timmy and Tommy on the sidelines.
"Our records show that this bastard was in the store on Day 6 and bought the medicine.
Take that!"

"Today is Day 7...
Hold it!"

"Ergo, it was bought yesterday!
It's so great how you know basic logic, Timmy!"

"To be fair though, Rock Stars don't seem bright enough to tell time without an assistant.
A rock band is only as good as their bassist."
Misterme7 wrote:
Hold it! Scenario 1a. is not possible! The damage to the walls and furniture was intentional, Whitney wasn't just blundering about with a shovel. Second, the body wounds were made post mortem. They barely bled.It's my skill, okay?

"Yes, but you're forgetting, if Whitney intended to frame someone for killing Cranston, maybe she could have beaten up the furniture in order to frame them."

"But that wouldn't make sense for her to use her own shovel for that... would it? Everything would point back to her..."

"Perhaps, and alternatively, this could point to Punchy framing Whitney for the murder... we'll leave that open to discuss later."

"And those wounds were made after Cranston died? Why on earth would someone hack up the body like that after killing him? Were they that mad at him over something?"