Dire wrote:
So... the partner and I had been avoiding this thread since we hadn't watched it. Now we have.
TL;DR: I didn't like it.
Spoiler for negative opinion.
For me, it wasn't just the ending. Pretty much everything from the moment she shows interest in Mako onwards sucked. There were a lot of things I liked too... but they are completely outweighed by what, I felt, was shitty story telling.
There were a lot of poor story choices that were made, a lot of unexplained plot threads, and a lot of late additions to the plot.
Animation and music was pretty awesome, though later on the music didn't stand out as much. The swing music early on was a sweet addition.
I think they might have also been missing a voice director. The voice actors themselves weren't that bad, some didn't fit the character and some just needed a bit of coaching to be a bit less flat.
Characterisation was hit and miss. Some characters were just swept under the rug entirely.
Too much new information was revealed in the second last episode due to the climax being pulled out of their asses.
Too little plot development leading up to the climax.
They missed out on dealing with a lot of complex themes and concepts and instead devoted way too much screen time to teen romance.
The ending for Amon and Tarlok was pretty good, though that plot device only turned up in episode 11. So it missed out on having the impact it could have had if it had been a simmering story thread.
We could go into so much detail as to what is wrong but we'd probably piss people off.
Just finished the series. Gah, pretty much this. All the hang-ups I had with the show were listed here. That and I didn't feel that the romance added much of anything to the story because it was as pointless and predictable as fuck.