Marcato wrote:
I tried reading the Lord of the Rings series when I was younger. I managed to get all the way to Return of the King before I couldn't take any more obscene amounts of description.
I'm expecting half of you to martyr me now.
I also quit the first time I tried, but after only 50 pages of irrelevant description of the hobbits. I managed to read all three books in three weeks this summer. I felt there was
not enough description, or, at least, not enough where it mattered. My favorite book is the second, I felt it was the most balanced one, and it had a better pace too.
The third one has the most unsatisfying ending ever. After Samwise does all the actual work and supports Frodo while on their way to Mount Doom, they manage to destroy the Ring and are then saved by
eagles, and we never know what happened to Sauron (unless I'm too dumb and didn't get it). Then
Arwen, who was only mentioned three times before and was never implied to have any kind of relationship with
Aragorn, marries him and everybody returns home.
Saroumane is killed anticlimactically, then Frodo departs for another continent with the Elves with no explanation given, leaving Sam behind to grow potatoes until he's 96, then he too is allowed to go, and that's it.
So yeah, I read it because it was a classic, but I don't think I'd read it again for fun.