Random thoughts time, I do feel like many Pokemon designs in the latest couple of gens are getting... I dunno, more complicated? The style is definitely different from first gen and I'm beginning to understand why Genwunners dislike them, they really are in a different style (at least for certain Pokes)
I suppose some of it can be contributed to the improving graphics - Gen 1 (and to some extent Gen 2) had a limited color palette so most of the Pokes from that era have just one or two colors. Compare that to
Bruxish's color swatch Jackson Pollock-lookin' disaster or even
Sigilyph's color scheme. More colors can be nicer looking and gives some more freedom in design, but there's a certain simplicity to Pokemon that mostly stick to a single color.
Better graphics also means you can show more detail, and I feel like the designers have responded to that by.. making Pokemon look more complicated than I think they need to be. I know a lot of people feel that way about many Mega Evolutions already, but I guess those are kind of meant to look over-the-top. I'm talking about more subtle details that don't really seem to serve a purpose other than "we noticed this Pokemon didn't look interesting/badass/visually cluttered enough, so here's some extra spots, stripes, and horns." For instance,
take a look at Vikavolt. I suppose he's meant to look like a bug, with those strong stag beetle jaws made to look like an electrical plug. Okay, cool. Why do those jaws need extra spikes coming out the side? what's up with that weird pentagonal frill behind its head? It has a weird mix of angular and round shapes, and while I think overall it looks cool, I also think its design could be simpler without losing much of what it is. In fact, losing a few spikes and corners would make its similarities to real-world things more clear, I think. There's also details like differing eye shapes (I'm seeing a lot more Pokemon with actual, like, eyelids? instead of triangles with dots in them.)
It's pretty clear to be the design style has changed, but who cares, right? Well, I honestly think that the change in design is a big reason so many people who are nostalgic about the early gens don't care about the later ones. Because they look at some newer designs, see a weird monster, and don't recognize any of the simple, clear design aspects of the early gens in the later ones. They're not as cute or badass as the ones they remember because the style is so different it may as well be a different franchise to them. You can really notice the change in Gen 1 pokes that got a new evolution later - For example, Magnemite and Magneton have a simple, easy to understand design - they're round, made of metal, and have magnets. But then when Magnezone shows up, it becomes a UFO?
I think a big reason for Pokemon Go's success was the fact that it only included Gen 1 Pokes. Maximized the nostalgia factor, and honestly, I think if they had included all the gens, a lot of people would be turned off by it just because they would have to get used to these creatures that don't have that characteristic "Pokemon" feel to them because the style is so different. Makes me wonder if it's a good idea for Niantic to consider adding later gens in the future or not...
Don't get me wrong, I still like a lot of new designs. And not all of them suffer from the "weirdness" problem. (
Cutiefly is a good example, looks
exactly like a real bee fly, nothing overcomplicated) but But I understand where people are coming from when they say they don't "get" the newer ones, they really are different. The problem isn't really "hurr why did they make a sentient ice cream cone", I think it has more to do with how the ice cream cone was drawn, it doesn't match the sentient sludge pile, gas cloud, and Pokeball-with-eyes Pokemon they're used to.
Why did I write all this? I need to go to bed.