Ame no Akai wrote:
You know what's fun? Try reading a upstanding member of society (or 'anthro', I'm not used to making a distinction) comic, and replace all upstanding member of society characters with normal humans. See if it changes anything.
Storywise, it often doesn't.
That applies to a lot of stuff though. An easy example is pointing to cartoons. Would it change anything if looney toons, or disney cartoons had human characters instead of anthro characters? Meh, well, I suppose you'd lose the Duck Season / Rabbit Season jokes.
Though I think it would be sad if we didn't have Mickey Mouse or Bugs Bunny in our childhood memories. Or hell, we'd lose characters like Pinky and the Brain, or Animaniacs.
...
On a side note, the only anthro comic I've read was Inverloch. In that story, yes, it would have mattered if you replaced the anthro characters with humans. Then again, that's because the story was based on three races... Typical Humans, Perfect Elves, and some sorta monsterish looking race to be hated by everyone else. Using anthro-goat/wolves makes them cuter and more sympathetic than using something like goblins.
[spoiler]But apparently, despite being reasonably cute and sympathetic, they were apparently justifyably hated. They did some pretty amoral things[/spoiler]
I'd actually recommend Inverloch, and probably shouldn't be talking about it in a bad webcomics thread. The beginning is a bit weak, but it really develops into a LotR'ish fantasy, with a pretty solid story and good characters. A part of me wishes the author would go back and clean up the first couple of chapters up to her newer art and writing quality.