SaintCrazy wrote:
Edit: Re: LotR: I recently started re-reading the LotR series, it makes a lot more sense than it did when I was in middle school, because you realize that it's not in the straightforward fantasy style of fiction you see today (including stuff like Elder Scrolls, even though their lore is more fleshed out than most fantasy worlds). It's more like... halfway between epic poetry and medieval fantasy. It really started the whole fantasy mythos as we know it, before LotR there really weren't any other well-known stories of elves and dwarves and monsters like that. So it's a lot more cryptic, partially because so much of it refers to lore that only Tolkien knew about (and later put in stuff like the Silmarillion), but also because that world was so different from other fiction of the time; it creates that feel that there are ancient secrets and powers at work that the mortal characters (or the readers) never really understand.
It's exactly because of this that Tolkien said the Lord of the Rings should include the Silmarillion. He felt that you could never grasp everything tLotR was about without knowing what happened before. He explained all this in the letter that was included in the Silmarillion.
Everything became much more clear to me when I learned that tLotR is actually the last bit, bodaciously the ending, of the entire story that was his life's work.