Barabba wrote:
Pierce straightens his back.

"Fine then. I'll just have to prove what you were really doing last night. With evidence."

"You're the one who stole the knife, weren't you? While everyone was leaving the plaza, you took the knife from the picnic table with the intent to kill. That would explain your erratic behavior yesterday. But how to commit the murder? Everyone was supposed to stay in their homes at nighttime, where you wouldn't be able to reach them."

"But then you overheard Diana talking about her lockpicks in her tool kit, and you knew this was your opportunity. You waited until she left her house and then snuck in, stealing the toolkit and replacing it with your bone. There were no signs of forced entry at Diana's house, so only one option remains for entry."
Evidence Bullet: Diana's Chimney

"Diana's chimney is too small for most animals to fit through, true..... But then again, you're a pretty small animal, Joe. You flew up to the chimney and entered Diana's house through that entrance."

"After that, you returned home and dug a hole, putting a certain item inside."
Evidence Bullet: Pitfall Seed

"You did this to prevent anyone from entering your home and finding the toolkit. In turn, this also proves that Diana couldn't have stolen your bone. She had no way of knowing about the Pitfall Seed, and would have been immediately trapped."

"You then waited until nighttime. Walking over to Bud's house, you began trying to pick his lock, with no success. Suddenly he came out of his house, surprising you."
Evidence Bullet: Bud's Door

"That's when you decided to attack him in front of his house. At some point during the fight, you lost the knife and fled, returning to your house. Realizing you lost it, you went out again to retrieve it, only to find Bud waiting for you."

"That's when he said the words that would be forever engrained in your memory."
Barabba wrote:
with him saying that he would kill me before I could kill him

"He attacked you with his shovel and dropped it, his knife falling out of his pocket in the process. You struggled with it, then accidentally stabbed him in the eye. Presuming him dead, you went back to your house to get your shovel and bury his body, only to find his body missing when you got back."

"And that's the whole truth, isn't it, Joe?!?!?"
_________________
[Citation Needed] wrote:
your superinsulatory properties have always been a founding tenet of our friendship