Dusty Rum Mutiny - ACHIEVEMENTS

AngelicSongx · **Posted:** Sat Jun 23, 2012 7:48 pm

I know that it's the most critical point of the game, but no one joined me on my suspicions, and it worked for us the first day. (But yes, I know that the first day and the most critical point of the game are not the same thing..)

Turbro · **Joined:** Fri Apr 29, 2011 9:11 am **Posts:** 5475

Honestly, I'm becoming suspicious of the people who are bandwagoning without thinking. Especially those who are doing so to

Need Runes4 wrote:

speed this up.

Cori · **Posted:** Sat Jun 23, 2012 7:53 pm

Same here...

Tetrunes · **Posted:** Sat Jun 23, 2012 7:55 pm

That was 1 part pun and 2 parts 'I don't want this game to go on forever'

Turbro · **Joined:** Fri Apr 29, 2011 9:11 am **Posts:** 5475

The more I think on it, the less supicious I am of Supaaku, and more suspicious of the people who are bodaciously voting for me because

Potato wrote:

Voting Turbo seems like the 'in' thing to do

Guyperson · **Posted:** Sat Jun 23, 2012 8:05 pm

At this point, the possibility of losing via bandwagon is funner than waiting forever. And if we didn't bandwagon, just how would we vote? You don't get a lynch by having 50 different vote trains going every direction, each without enough votes to actually get a lynch.

Turbro · **Joined:** Fri Apr 29, 2011 9:11 am **Posts:** 5475

I'd still rather I die and us lose due to actual suspicion/convincing arguments for my guilt rather than people bandwagoning just because.

Guyperson · **Posted:** Sat Jun 23, 2012 9:24 pm

We can't give convincing arguments because all our power roles are dead, and unable to grant us the evidence that makes convincing arguments convincing. I don't think being slightly suspicious is a good indicator for a lynch either, stupidity plays a big role in good guys acting suspicious. Now, Darkin/Brekk levels of suspicious, yeah, I'd vote for that, but the only one close to those levels right now is Fat old robot. But here's the thing: he's the cannoneer's scapegoat. The cannoneer would never, from day1, act suspicious at that level. Voting FoR is a guaranteed mute hit, but also a gauranteed cannoneer shooting another matey tonight death. Were the cannoneer not at large, he'd be at the top of the hit list, but he is at large, so random bandwagoning is safer.

Turbro · **Joined:** Fri Apr 29, 2011 9:11 am **Posts:** 5475

Guyperson wrote:

We can't give convincing arguments because all our power roles are dead, and unable to grant us the evidence that makes convincing arguments convincing.

Who voted similar to Brekk on previous days? Who did Brekk vote for and when? Who opposed brekk the most? We have evidence, it's just very, VERY hard to use efficiently.

Guyperson wrote:

Now, Darkin/Brekk levels of suspicious, yeah, I'd vote for that, but the only one close to those levels right now is Fat old robot. But here's the thing: he's the cannoneer's scapegoat. The cannoneer would never, from day1, act suspicious at that level. Voting FoR is a guaranteed mute hit, but also a gauranteed cannoneer shooting another matey tonight death.

So you're saying we know who a mutie is, but we're intentionally not voting for him because the cannoner might kill someone?
You'd rather a 50-50 chance of hitting someone who might be a mutie, and automatically losing if we're wrong, over a 100% chance of hitting a mutie and a 50% chance someone else will die, potentially buying us another day?

This is of course, assuming you're right about Robot.
And if you knew that Robot was a matey, why didn't you vote for him before?

Supaaku · **Joined:** Sun Mar 06, 2011 6:14 am **Posts:** 1215

Made a new list of how I've seen people acting over the course of the game. I'd suggest that everyone who's voted thus far also make a list.
Leave yourself blank. It's a given that everyone will view themselves innocent.

Need Runes4 - (S) Jumps on bandwagons. Jumpy in general
ShadowGuy - (I) Backs up his reasons for voting
Cori - (U) Seems fairly neutral
TurboPunz - (S) I'm beginning to think is Cannoneer since mutineers are hesitant to vote even if it removes suspicion from themselves. Granted, it's conjecture
D-vid - (S) Started off the votes against both Noff and Crisp. Didn't vote for Brekkjern. Could just be timezone shenanigans however
electronic goat - (S) Jumpy. Didn't vote for Brekkjern
Lord Retardus - (U) Quiet. Maybe too quiet
Potato - (S) Jumps on bandwagons without giving reasons for doing so
Angelicsongx - (S) Jumps on bandwagons without giving reasons for doing so
Saximaphone - (S) Didn't vote Darkin. Voted for Noff and Crisp
Supaaku - (N/A) I know how I view myself in this but that won't change anyone else's view of me
Guyperson - (U) Jumpy
Somepartsareme - (U) Quiet. Still votes though
FatOldRobot - (S) Usually votes to 'speed things up'

Guyperson · **Posted:** Sat Jun 23, 2012 10:36 pm

TurboPunz wrote:

So you're saying we know who a mutie is, but we're intentionally not voting for him because the cannoner might kill someone?

Might? There is nothing for the cannoneer to lose now, his firing is a certainty, so he takes precedence over a muti who can barely even hide his mutinism.

Quote:

You'd rather a 50-50 chance of hitting someone who might be a mutie, and automatically losing if we're wrong, over a 100% chance of hitting a mutie and a 50% chance someone else will die, potentially buying us another day?

This is of course, assuming you're right about Robot.
And if you knew that Robot was a matey, why didn't you vote for him before?

Because I DON'T know Robot is a matey/muti, it's just a guess. A good guess, but still a guess. And either way, there is no way in hell he's the cannoneer, the actual threat right now.

ShadowGuy · **Posted:** Sat Jun 23, 2012 11:42 pm

I technically haven't voted, but I don't see any problem with doing this:

Need Runes4 - (U) Day 6 voted Turbo but changed to a different option, illogical for mafia. But he has been acting suspicious in a few ways. If I had to, I'd say town.
ShadowGuy - (N/A) Self explanatory.
Cori - (I) Checks all options and not too hasty with voting.
TurboPunz - (S) Has yet to be band-wagoned to death by mafia despite several votes, so unlikely to be town. However, it could be a ploy by mafia if there aren't 2 or more town votes on Turbo.
D-vid - (I) Day 6 voted Turbo but changed to a different option. Not too hasty to vote.
electronic goat - (S) Didn't vote for Brekkjern, hasn't contributed much.
Lord Retardus - (U) He doesn't talk much. I have no idea.
Potato - (U) I don't see what the problem with jumping on bandwagons with no reason given since the bandwagon would have to have been started using logic. I'd probably lean more towards mafia.
Angelicsongx - (U) Same as Potato, but seems more town than mafia due to contributing when needed.
Saximaphone - (U) He did vote for the now-deceased innocents, but he was the one to hammer-vote (when 1 vote is left to day lynch) Brekk, a mafia. Would probably lean more towards town.
Supaaku - (U) Mixed feelings. Acts Mafia in some ways, yet balances it out with town beneficial suggestions. If I had to choose, I'd probably pick town.
Guyperson - (S) Apparently FatOldRobot is a guaranteed mafia hit, but it is also apparently a good guess? I don't find contradicting oneself town-like.
Somepartsareme - (U) Votes. Quiet.
FatOldRobot - (S) Votes to speed things up, claims to not be paying much attention to the thread.

Turbro · **Joined:** Fri Apr 29, 2011 9:11 am **Posts:** 5475

Fine, you know what? I'm done. I have no idea how I can make it more obvious that bandwagoning is a bad idea right now, especially on me of all people. And since none of you are listening:

Lynch TurboPunz and get this shit over with.

Turbro · **Joined:** Fri Apr 29, 2011 9:11 am **Posts:** 5475

inb4 "hes just doing this to get sympathy"

Sol Reaper · **Posted:** Sun Jun 24, 2012 1:39 am

Current Votes

AngelicSongx - FatOldRobot, then TurboPunz
Supaaku - TurboPunz
Guyperson - AngelicSongx, then TurboPunz
D-vid - TurboPunz, then Undecided
Need Runes4 - TurboPunz, then Undecided, then Supaaku, then TurboPunz
electronic goat - TurboPunz
Potato - TurboPunz
TurboPunz - Supaaku, then Himself

With 14 alive, it takes 8 to lynch.

Popular Lynches

TurboPunz - 7 votes, 1 more vote to lynch

AWKWARD ZOMBIE

Dusty Rum Mutiny - ACHIEVEMENTS

Who is online