AWKWARD ZOMBIE

I take my sweet sweet time thinking the mafia thread hasn't gone to day, and when I come back not only is it 4 pages longer but I didn't even get a gun!
Take a hint gunsmith! Being powerless villager is boring!

Now, I'm gonna take a guess that they got ugg-huer because they didn't want a quiet, adds-no-fun villager sticking around for the penultimate day.

Anyway, we're back to the whole "no actual evidence" thing we've had for the past few days, except now all our "suspicion" tables are filled up. SO, we can either hope for a reveal from someone, or just go with our suspicion tables. Since I can only reveal my role as villager, I say we go with the second option. LYNCH D-VID.

BTW I'm a villager.

Youre mentioning that youre just a villager a lot.

Angelic, I didn't mention I was shocked at the inspector roles dying because I didn't think it was productive. Of course I was suprized, the mafia ganked our two best roles for picking a lynch.
I don't remember thinking you as suspect, reyo, and if I did, I don't anymore.

I don't have a suspicion list per se, but I do have a fear: Kamak is Exeres-ing us.

Given crisp also claimed villager, despite being mafia, I don't thingpk claiming villager means anything.

@runes, the list includes votes to lynch, which I remember you doing day 3.

True, claiming villager is a meaningless, unprovable claim. Actually, if I'm the miller, it's important I inform everyone now that I'm a villager in case of my sudden death, so they don't get confused on the real number of mafia remaining. So there's that. There's also the fact that it's fun to repeat constantly that I'm the villager, possibly mess with a mafia's head or two. I guess the last reason is because I'm a villager, and that's just what villagers do.

Yeah, I don't know why you're pressing this so much, kamak. All it's going to do is give the mafia a clear idea of who to hook at night.

I will reveal this tidbit of info: I was hooked last night. Since I am not a power role, this tells me that the mafia does not have any idea who our power roles are. As long as they remain clueless, we have the advantage of keeping our power roles.

I know all you have is my word on this, and saying I'm just a villager means little, but I know they have no idea what they're doing. Giving them more information will not go over well.

Also, Guy, if you claim villager and show up mafia, there's an equal chance you were just mafia and were lying to us.

I'm pretty sure Guy is just claiming villager repeatedly as a joke.

Guy's constant reminding us of his status as a villager is getting annoying to be honest.

I don't even know if I should be suspicious of his claim or not.

I looked back through the thread, and noted the order of lynch votes for certain people.

DAY 2:
I voted to lynch egoat (joke)

Runes voted to lynch Cynic
D-Vid voted to lynch Cynic

Turbo voted to lynch me
Runes changed vote to lynch me

Guyperson voted to lynch Cynic (didn't have it in bold)

Angel went undecided
Cori went undecided

Tam voted to lynch Cynic

Saint voted to lynch Tam

Angel changed vote to lynch Cynic
Cori changed vote to lynch Cynic
Crisp voted to lynch Cynic (mafia)
I voted to lynch Cynic
Cynic was lynched (villager)

And then just the ones for Cynic in the order they came:
Runes
D-Vid
Guyperson
Tam
Angel
Cori
Crisp
Me

Day 3:
Runes voted to lynch Alec

Runes changed vote to undecided

Saint voted to lynch D-Vid

D-Vid voted to lynch Tam
Runes changed vote to lynch Tam

D-Vid changed vote to lynch Runes

Guyperson voted to lynch D-Vid
Kamak voted to lynch D-Vid
Cori voted to lynch D-Vid
Angel voted to lynch D-Vid
Alec voted to lynch D-Vid (villager)

Saint changed vote to undecided
Angel changed vote to undecided
Kamak changed vote to undecided

Alec reaffirmed vote for D-Vid (villager)

Kamak voted to lynch Alec
Guyperson changed voted to lynch Alec
Turbo voted to lynch Alec
Runes changed vote to lynch Alec
I voted to lynch Alec
Cori voted to lynch Alec
Tam voted to lynch Alec
Alec was lynched (villager)

Now just the ones that were for D-Vid (since it was 1 away from a lynch):
Saint
Guyperson
Kamak
Cori
Angel
Alec

And then for Alec:
Runes (revoked)
Kamak
Guyperson
Turbo
Runes
Me
Cori
Tam

And that just leaves today.
Here's a list, per person, of the orders that they voted to lynch (in the order of cynic, d-vid, and alec)

Saint: n/a, 1, n/a
Cori: 6, 4, 7
Turbo: n/a, n/a, 4
Me: 8, n/a, 6
Tam: 4, n/a, 8
Guyperson: 3, 2, 3
Kamak: n/a, 3, 2
Runes: 1, n/a, 1
Angel: 5, 5, n/a
D-Vid: 2, n/a, n/a

Alec: n/a, 6, n/a (villager)
Crisp: 7, dead, dead (mafia)

And now the orders in a format that's not total eye rape.
(0 indicates they didn't vote)

(0,1,0) Saint
(6,4,7) Cori
(0,0,4) Turbo
(8,0,6) Me
(4,0,8) Tam
(3,2,3) Guyperson
(0,3,2) Kamak
(1,0,1) Runes
(5,5,0) Angel
(2,0,0) D-Vid

(0,6,0) Alec (villager)
(7,0,0) Crisp (mafia)

Order:
(Cynic, D-Vid, Alec)

Data is nice and all, its just a question of how we interpretation it.

Working on a chart that'll hopefully be useful. Will have it ready sometime tonight maybe.

Indeed. Do we go after who voted early on innocent lynches? Late? Middle? You could formulate a reason to go for either.

Ah, statistics. The art of bending the truth to one's will.

I was thinking of making a chart myself, but I won't have time for until this weekend, maybe. Then again maybe kamak's will serve the same role. if he was thinking what I was thinking.

I think he is, but where will you get a tub filled with cream cheese?