AWKWARD ZOMBIE

We know that Supaaku isn't the cannoneer, though.

But he is still a mutineer candidate, and I'm waiting for a few more testimonies before I decide on what other candidate may be the cannoneer. This is kind of a placeholder in case the thunderstorms knock my internet out.

Also, I don't feel that there should be a time limit on a day if we're having an actual discussion, it'll just lead to rash choices.

I understand wanting to move the game along, but either increase the time limit or change the way it starts, the days feel too compacted.

Sol won't be back until 10 Central US, But yeah, I think the time should be at the most five days.

So, we're going to vote the people who last minute voted? I kinda see them as wanting to get their word in, or at least make the day go faster. But, whatever you guys want to do, I guess. I'll just wait for them to try and defend themselves, if that's fine. I'll rush my vote in later.

Guyperson, The Cannoneer is the biggest threat at this point. I've already said why I went after Oracle on Day 2. Turns out I was wrong and I should have realised sooner how complex the conditions for Oracle to not be Drunken Pirate would have been. If you still want to lynch me later, fine. As suspicious as this sounds, I'm just a Matey. Only my death or the end game can prove that though.

As for who the Cannoneer is, I haven't the foggiest idea. My best guess would be D-vid but there's absolutely nothing to back that up except he seemed to know for a fact that Oracle was innocent and was the first to vote for lynching Noff. His reasoning being that even without Darkin saying Noff was a mutineer we would have lynched him anyway. Noff only had one vote against him for the entirety of Day 1. I don't think he was in any danger of a lynch without Darkin's accusation. In other words, it's just a hunch that D-vid is not Ship-sided. So yeah. It's either going to be a random pick of the three listed earlier or D-vid, who I just can't shake getting Mutineer vibes from.

Note on time limit

If you're still having active, constructive discussion I won't end the day prematurely.

Alright, how about we decide like this.

Everyone take a list of who is still alive, take Oracle and Supaaku out of the equation, and list who you think is S (suspicious), U (Unsure), or I (Innocent)

We'll count up the S votes and I votes and see who seems most suspicious in the bunch and choose them for lynching.

TO BE FAIR IN VOTING. PLEASE VOTE UNSURE OR SOMETHING TO THAT EFFECT RATHER THAN SAYING YOUR INNOCENT. We want what other people think of you, not what you think of yourself.

Need Runes4-U
ShadowGuy-S
Cori-U
TurboPunz-U
D-vid-U
electronic goat-U
Lord Retardus-U
Potato-U
Angelicsongx-U
Kubein-S
Saximaphone-U
Kamak-U
Guyperson-S
Somepartsareme-U
FatOldRobot-U
Crisp-S

Don't debate/browbeat people on how they vote. We need to try to decide soon and causing a debate over "Why would you accuse me? I've done nothing wrong" can cause issues. Once the votes are tallied, we'll decide between the highest suspicious people and hear them out.

Sound like a plan?

Need Runes4-U
ShadowGuy-S
Cori-I
TurboPunz-S
D-vid-I
electronic goat-S
Lord Retardus-U
Potato-U
Angelicsongx-U
Kubein-S
Saximaphone-U
Kamak-I
Guyperson-S
Somepartsareme-U
FatOldRobot-U
Crisp-S

I'm reading through the thread in it's entirety right now, in order to get as clear evidence as I can before making rash decisions.

This is the most organized I've ever seen any mafia game. You all got an achievement.



Just so you know I'm making achievement badges instead of userbars for this game

I would try to fill out that chart but I am unsure about EVERYONE right now. I had a hard time following all of the arguments and counters and now I'm just very confused.

I feel like kind of a dunce right now...

Okay now I have a small guilty chart now. btw, Supaaku, you're downgraded from suspicious to unsure.
But the possible mutant list.
Saximaphone
Crisp
Fat old robot
Brekk
Cori

Unsure
Kamak
Dvid
Turbo
EGoat
Lord Retardus
Guyperson
Anyone I don't name

Innocent
Idiotic Oracle
Need_runes

My guilt charts were thrown waaaaaay off by the individuality and occasional stupidity of the confirmed pirates. As in, those that are already dead.

Need Runes4-U
ShadowGuy-U
Cori-U
TurboPunz-S
D-vid-S
electronic goat-S
Lord Retardus-U
Potato-U
Angelicsongx-U
Kubein-S
Saximaphone-U
Kamak-U
Guyperson-U
Somepartsareme-U
FatOldRobot-S
Crisp-S