Marcato wrote:
YCobb wrote:
Alright, so. Here's my theory so far. Now that Barabba has all but confirmed my innocence, I feel safe enough saying that I'm not poisoned. I was visited by /u000 last night, as Reyo said, but Granny Benson also visited me and since he's the jailer I was protected.
Putting this together with what Reyo was able to tell us before he died, Cori was visited on Night 1 by:
-Barabba (First Mate/Investigator)
-Granny Benson (jailer)
-Marcato
So what was Marcato doing there? Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe the only remaining roles that can visit people are Seductress and Mutineer. Since Benson says he was seduced that night, I propose that Marcato is the mutineer. We could suspect Benson of something shady here, but his name will be demonstrably cleared when the poison doesn't kill me tomorrow.
Any counterarguments, Marcato?
A mutineer, says you? Hmm..... To be sure, your logic has merit, says I. But I wonder if there isn't another possibility that's been overlooked, like an unclaimed role?
Hmm hmmmmmmmm golly gee.
Lynch Marcato. Today's open and shut, y'all.
To reiterate the reasoning: Marcato and Barabba visited Cori night one. Benson tried to, but was blocked by Chopstix, the seductress (though due to an administrative error, Reyo wasn't made aware that Benson got blocked)
Barabba was First Mate. The only visiting role left is Mutineer now that we know Turbo was carpenter, which tells us that Marcato converted Cori N1.
Login
Register
FAQ
Search
