FlyingGiraffe wrote:
Reyo, I went with the vote for two reasons: 1) Kergan was genuinely suspicious to me, in that he was pushing for Cori as a "lead", as though there was something to go off of besides the Raven's random vote, plus I find the act of pushing for a lynch without voting to lynch to be rather scummy, and 2) nothing was happening and I figured a vote would bring some life back to the thread.
I also do trust Cori to a degree, as he voted for me in the captain election and I am town-sided, actions that seem rather counterproductive and unnecessary for a werewolf to do. If we're looking towards suspicious persons I'm sticking to my guns.
That's not very good criteria for being scummy, because then anyone who simply suggests a suspicion is scummy. I do it all the time. I did it to you just now. For one, he didn't even really "push" for us to lynch cori. Kergan suggested we look at Cori, but then didn't say anything else after that, nor did he even throw his vote down until now, when it was brought into question whether he was really voting for him to be lynched. Had he instead kept bringing it up, making sure every other comment in the thread was "Hey guys, we need to lynch Cori." then I'd agree with you, but he simply brought it up as a possibility and didn't say anything else on the matter because no one else kept rolling with it.
And second, you are correct that throwing a vote down brought life back to the thread, but you did so in a way that makes me want to suspect you of being scum. Right now your actions are slighhtly more suspicious than Kergan's.
You obviously have a good reason to want to trust Cori, but your reasons for gunning for Kergan are fairly weak. I realize that Kergan could very well be a warewolf, but given that we don't know who anyone is, aside from ourselves, it's just as, if not more, possible for him to be a townie. I'd much rather hold off any of my own votes until someone does something so overly suspicious that I can't help but notice them. I do agree that Kergan's simple suggestion to go along with the raven vote is a bit suspicious, but the fact that you were then eager to jump on it is a little hasty in my mind. Especially since the original reasons for the suspicion were actually weaker than I thought they were. Personally, I'd have just brought it up to him for him to defend, which would then have probably lead me to voting for him, or someone else depending on who else was under suspicion (like wasn't Ycobb in the same boat, srsly...)
It's just the hasty vote makes me want to suspect you as much as I wasp t to suspect kergan.
_________________

Game Angel wrote:
"I have a penis but I'm not 100% sure it's a penis"