Time to clear up something about the medicine. It is both ingestible AND topical. When used topically, it cures bee stings and bites. When ingested it's a powerful drug that knocks you out and heals your illnesses like colds. If Whitney had it applied topically, all it'd do is clear up her skin/fur. Probably didn't word it right earlier.Marcato wrote:

"....I'm curious about this bottle of medicine. Perhaps when we uncover it's secrets, we can lay this case to rest."
What's the protocol for asking for a scenario regarding specific evidence? Just ask. :P
"Okay let me see if I can focus on the facts of the medicine."
Scenario 2"Punchy bought a bottle of medicine yesterday. Sometime later, he claims to have used the bottle of medicine on himself, putting the empty bottle in the closet."
"Tom Nook placed at least one new bottle in the closet, whereupon Punchy was capable of using either the original bottle or a second bottle to drug Whitney."
"Ultimately, one bottle was unused, and was the only item located in the closet when investigated."
"This is pretty weird..."
Cori wrote:

"But I don't think Punchy was even near me that day..." The wolf was starting to look even more doubtful--and fearful. "...Isabelle, do you still have that feather you found?" she asked hesitantly. "I would like to see it."

"Oh, right, the feather! I put it over on the desk there. Tom, could you hand it over."

"No, I don't think I will." he says with a sinister smile.

"Wh-What?" Isabelle says.

"This is what you bastards refer to as "definitive proof" and the mayor doesn't want you to have it yet. You'll have to figure some things out before I'm willing to show you this feather."

"You can ask Isabelle for testimony about the feather... but perhaps her memory is a bit... fuzzy... upupu~"

"Tom... what are you up to?"
Misterme7 wrote:
"So it's topical? So it's nearly impossible for her not to notice, most likely. And the red herrings could be a red herring in itself, for she could have reversed psychology and faked evidence with her own shovel to try and get people confused."
And tin foil hat off.

"You really lucked through school, didn't you?"